Experience Amara Cay

Indulge, Explore, AND RESTORE

On Islamorada in the Florida Keys, Amara Cay Resort calls to a certain kind of traveler: the traveler who sees our island setting as more than a spot to swing the days away in a hammock (though we have those, too). We’re talking to the traveler who sees our signature spaces—including a private beach, pool, marina, courtyard and Tiki Bar where the Gulf of Mexico meets the Atlantic Ocean—as an invitation to indulge their passions and curiosity.

Our aesthetic is modern; our vibe is active, social, engaged—like you. Because you crave life’s experiences, we curate some for you, and give you latitude to curate others for yourself. That might mean joining in for snorkeling, paddleboard yoga or stargazing. Making new friends over lawn games in the courtyard. Meeting up for coffee or cocktails. Gathering around for a dining experience at one of our four on-site restaurants and bars in the Florida Keys. Coming together for a wedding, reunion, girls weekend, meeting . . . or any other moment you’re seeking to create. So wander in and join in. We’re all friends here, brought together by our craving for life. At Amara Cay Resort, we strive for guests to experience a truly blissful retreat, inspired by the lush tropical surrounding of Islamorada. While our waterfront setting may make it easy to be carefree, we take hospitality seriously. 

Choose Your Adventure:


At the Resort


By The Water


On The Island

florida green lodging

We Are


to be acknowledged by Florida Green Lodging for our commitment to the environment and look forward to keeping Islamorada beautiful for years to come.

Amenities & Services

  • Private beach with hammocks, thatched huts, and pier
  • Elevated sunning beach, protected by a private seaside dock
  • Zero-entry pool
  • Tiki Bar
  • ReelCatch
  • Fitness Center (6am–10pm)
  • Gift shop and onsite convenience store
  • Meeting space
  • Shuttle (complimentary shuttle within four-mile radius)
  • Lawn games for all ages
  • Bicycles
  • Water sports excursions (kayaking and paddleboarding)
  • Evening fire pits
  • Daily housekeeping
  • Complimentary parking
  • Wi-fi available throughout public spaces
Stay & Explore


When you stay at one of the resorts in the Islamorada Resort Collection, you'll have access to explore the unique amenities, events, and restaurants of four resorts. Guests enjoy free shuttle service between each resort as well as nearby attractions.

Postcard Inn Resort & Marina  Pelican Cove Resort & Marina  La Siesta Resort & Villas


Celebrate The Florida Keys’ 200th anniversary and the island’s place in Florida’s history.

Learn More



“Love, love, love this place. Everything is pretty, well kept and clean. Palm trees by day & fire pit by night plus all the lawn games, pool, & tiki bar. Do yourself a favor & stay.”
– Christie

“The views are amazing, the pool is tranquil, the beach is spectacular and the rooms are quite nice! Would definitely come back for another stay!”
– Lisa

“Highly recommended this hotel. No need to drive all the way down to Key West. Islamorada has so much to offer. This hotel is a true example of that.”
– Brandon

Experience Our Other Islamorada Resorts

lasiesta logo
pelicancovehotel logo
Postcar Inn Logo