Four Resorts. One Island.

Passport to Paradise

Enjoy savings up to $100 when you get your passport stamped at Amara Cay and sister resorts, just a few minutes away by complimentary shuttle. Four unique resorts and thoughtful included amenities are at your disposal for a tropical getaway like no other. From Original Rum Runners at Postcard Inn's World Famous Tiki Bar to beachy Islamorada swag, there are plenty of benefits exclusive to your Passport to Paradise. Discover your secret oasis at Amara Cay and experience all the island adventures just steps from your door. Book our special rate and receive an Islamorada passport, good for special gifts and discounts, at check-in.

Plus, collect all four resort stamps by visiting the front desk at each property and redeem a special savings code for your next Islamorada retreat.

Passport to Paradise Savings include:

  • Islamorada Swag Bucket – Islamorada Resort Collection sandbucket, Amara Cay glasses, beverage cozies, sunblock, 10% off Amara Cay Tiki Bar coupon
  • 2 Original Rum Runners at the Holiday Isle Tiki Bar
  • La Siesta Buff
  • Abel’s shot glass
Book now

Offer is based on availability. Not valid with existing reservations. Offer valid to book now through May 31, 2021 for stays from February 1, 2021 through September 30, 2021. Minimum length of stay is 2 nights. Blackout dates may apply.

What People



I can’t fault a single thing with this hotel! As soon as we entered we were checked in by the most helpful and cheerful member of staff! (I wish I’d got his name so I could mention him!) We were upgraded to a suite as we had mentioned we were staying for our anniversary. The room was spacious and well equipped, with a lounge area, kitchen and separate bedroom.



We stayed at Amara Cay last week, and it was great. It was clean and the staff was friendly and helpful. The resort had everything we needed, including a shuttle in to town, kayaks, bikes, etc. We had a nice and very relaxing trip. (It helped that the weather was ideal)

Read more reviews