Calling all AARP members! Enjoy up to 20% off our best available rates when you book direct.

AAA membership card is required at check-in. Book online or call (305) 664-0073 and mention rate plan AARP.


Exclusive Offer

AARP Members!

"Amazing!! Paradise in a fishing world! Would stay again!"

After 25 hours of driving and pulling up to a hotel like this, words cannot describe how grateful I was. This is a fishing town so choice of hotels is slim it’s not a resort town. After walking up to the bar seeing the white sand beach, ocean, hammocks, palms, and pool, I was sold. Free Kayaks and paddle boards to take out the hotel has right there too! They even have games to play outside, fire pits, and a pier to fish off of. Highly recommend this place. We will be back again for sure!
- ledzepland

"Awesome Islamarada Resort"

We loved everything about Amara Cay Resort. Situated in a terrific section of the keys located to many great restaurants and activities. The resort was beautiful. You can tell the great attention to detail and customer service is a priority at this place and among the management team. Great pool, beautiful property, and staff. We have recommended this resort to numerous people and most definitely will return again soon!
- Laura N

"Gorgeous Property!"

Having never been to the Keys before, we were nervous about staying along the way to Key West from Miami. I must say I was thrilled when we walked into Amara Cay. Photos don't do the property justice! It's beautifully decorated and the staff is friendly and attentive. We had the most beautiful Ocean Front Suite with Kitchenette and two bathrooms! We have stayed in many Ocean View and Ocean Front rooms and I have never been so close to the ocean. It's such a relaxing place with pool, kayaks and paddleboards available to use. Our only regret was not staying for two nights!
- kdundas

"Views galore"

Watching the sunset from a beachfront room does not get any better. The waitstaff and staff are very helpful and friendly. Water view hammocks to relax in and the walk-in pool is great. I'm Planning a trip back and will rebook there.
- lauraduksa

"Great Experience"

First time staying here and we weren't disappointed. Rates were good, beautiful pool, great food and attentive staff. We'll stay here again. The room was spacious with a beautiful view and clean. We ate lunch at the hotel twice and loved it both times. Check this place out.
- Chris K

Don't Miss Out, Book Now!

Thank You