Two fishing rods over a boat in the deep blue sea

Our onsite dive shop, Sea Monkey’s, is a one-stop source for everything you need to get out and enjoy the calm, clear waters of the Florida Keys. Sea Monkey’s offers wave runner, sea kayak, paddleboard, boat, and bicycle rentals, as well as full dive certification programs, refresher courses and referral/check-out dives. You’ll also find snorkel gear, dive accessories and some of the island’s best t-shirts and gifts.

In addition, the resort is in close proximity to the Theater of the Sea, offering easy access to this renowned attraction’s eco-tours and range of interactive animal programs, including “Swim with the Dolphins” and “Trainer for the Day.”

It is rumored that Islamorada is home to a larger fishing fleet per square mile than anywhere else in the world so it’s only natural that islanders stake their claim to the nickname “Sport Fishing Capital of the World.” This tropical paradise has the largest charter fleet available anywhere for both backcountry and deep-sea excursions to fishing grounds unparalleled in the world.

Whether you’re an experienced angler or baiting your first hook, local captains can take you anywhere – from the Atlantic shoreline to the mangrove-lined bays and canals of the Everglades in search of a trophy-worthy fish, including dolphin, yellowtail, bonefish, redfish, tarpon and sea trout. From deep-sea fishing to fly- and spin-fishing, local captains know these waters well.

Our first recommendation for the finest fishing fleet is Postcard Inn Islamorada Marina, located Oceanside at the South End of Windley Key in Islamorada, Florida. To contact, call 305-664-2321 ext. 641 or email

Ready to explore the colorful world below the surface? Make Sea Monkey’s, our onsite dive shop, your first – and only – stop. Sea Monkey’s specializes in small group diving excursions aboard its 02 27-foot May Craft custom dive boat, the fastest dive boat in the Upper Keys. Its Six-Pac Dive accommodates just six divers for highly personalized excursions to well-known dive sites and hidden gems including Alligator Reef, Conch Reef & Wall, Crocker Drop-Off and The Eagle.

Indulge in Islamorada’s Best Seaside Shopping
Island Trendz at Amara Cay is open 7 days a week. Selling the most stylish resort wear, sundries, and souvenirs, they also boast specialty items such as dive watches, organic soy candles, jewelry, sun hats and handbags.

Island Trendz Hours of Operation
Monday-Thursday | 8:00am - 8:00pm
Friday-Sunday | 8:00am - 9:30pm.

Amara Cay Pop In Savings

Thank You