Dining
Oceanfront Dining
Nourish YOURSELF
Amara Cay Resort's restaurant and bar draw locals and guests for beautifully prepared cuisine that’s anchored in the traditions of the Florida Keys. No matter the time of day, you can indulge at ReelCatch, Coastal Cup, or the Tiki Bar. Whether you crave a simple burger or a custom-blended treat, our team will create a memorable experience. For more information on our menu or hours, please see below.
TIKI BAR
Lunch and Dinner
Every Day: 11 am - 9 pm
Bar
Sunday – Thursday: 11 am – 9 pm
Fridays and Saturdays: 11 am – 11 pm
Open for lunch and dinner, Tiki Bar is a breezy poolside spot for classic American cuisine and tropical cocktails against a backdrop of blue skies and swaying palm trees. Fresh fish tacos, grilled jumbo shrimp and Key lime pie are among the menu highlights.
See menu
REELCATCH
Breakfast
Weekdays: 8 am – 10 am
Weekends: 8 am – 11 am
Dinner
Weekdays: 5 pm - 9 pm
Weekends: 5 pm - 10 pm
Islamorada’s favorite gathering spot for fun and adventure, our onsite restaurant ReelCatch anchors locals and guests alike with Island favorites, fresh fish, and Keys-inspired cocktails.
See menu
Coastal Cup & Lounge
Breakfast Grab 'N Go
Open Daily: 7 am – 12 pm
Bar
Wednesday, Thursday & Sunday: 6 pm - 10 pm
Friday - Saturday: 6 pm - 11 pm
From coffee to cocktails, Coastal Cup & Lounge is where guests and locals go to start and end their days. Wake up and enjoy specialty coffees and delicious pastries, and then return in the evening for refreshing drinks and tapas accompanied by the acoustic sounds from local musicians.
IN-ROOM DINING
Open Daily: 8 am - 10 am | 12 pm - 8 pm
Have your Amara Cay favorites delivered directly to you!
See menu
Stay & Explore
STAY & EXPLORE ALL 4
When you stay at one of the resorts in the Islamorada Resort Collection, you'll have access to explore the unique amenities, events, and restaurants of four resorts. Guests enjoy free shuttle service between each resort as well as nearby attractions.
Postcard Inn Resort & Marina Pelican Cove Resort & Marina La Siesta Resort & Villas#amaracayawaits
“Love, love, love this place. Everything is pretty, well kept and clean. Palm trees by day & fire pit by night plus all the lawn games, pool, & tiki bar. Do yourself a favor & stay.”
– Christie
“The views are amazing, the pool is tranquil, the beach is spectacular and the rooms are quite nice! Would definitely come back for another stay!”
– Lisa
“Highly recommended this hotel. No need to drive all the way down to Key West. Islamorada has so much to offer. This hotel is a true example of that.”
– Brandon
Stay Connected
Islamorada Resort Collection 
80001 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, FL 33036
Hotel: 305-664-0073 | Reservations: (844) 918-0516
Amara Cay Resort © 2023 All Rights Reserved
