Indulge, Explore,


At Amara Cay Resort, we strive for guests to experience a truly blissful retreat, inspired by the lush tropical surrounding of Islamorada. While our waterfront setting may make it easy to be carefree, we take hospitality seriously. After all, this is the Sport Fishing Capital of the World.

The resort’s $35 per day resort fee includes access to high-speed Internet access, parking, unlimited use of beach chairs and pool towels, a Mercedes van to shuttle guests within a four-mile radius, in-room bottled water, access to the fitness center, pool towel service, bicycles, kayaks, paddle boards, lawn games (ping pong and corn hole) and more.



Our thoughtfully designed collection of resort amenities and services is what makes us stand out from the rest. From our non-motorized water sports activities to our evening fire pits, there’s always something to do at Amara Cay Resort.


Amenities & Services

  • Private beach with hammocks, thatched huts, and pier
  • Elevated sunning beach, protected by a private seaside dock
  • Zero-entry pool
  • Tiki Bar
  • Reelburger
  • Fitness Center (6am–10pm)
  • Gift shop and onsite convenience store
  • Meeting space
  • Shuttle (complimentary shuttle within four-mile radius)
  • Lawn games for all ages
  • Bicycles
  • Water sports excursions (kayaking and paddleboarding)
  • Evening fire pits
  • Daily housekeeping
  • Complimentary parking
  • Wi-fi available throughout public spaces

A Laid-Back


Located in the Florida Keys, halfway between Key West and Miami, Islamorada is known for its crystal clear waters, sandy beaches lined with palm trees, breathtaking orchids and bougainvillea, and one-of-a-kind sunsets.


What's On


Indulge in made-to-order burgers and more classic American treats at our very own restaurant, Reelburger, or head to Reelburger’s Tiki Bar for some Keys-inspired cuisine and refreshing island cocktails.



80001 Overseas Hwy | (305) 664-0095

Island Trendz Boutique

Selling the most stylish resort wear, sundries, and souvenirs, Island Trendz also boasts specialty items such as dive watches, organic soy candles, jewelry, sun hats, and handbags.