Insiders' Guide

A Well-Crafted Taco Is A Beautiful Thing

Fish tacos. Ah. The sweet allure of fresh ocean-to-table fish delicately folded in flour tortillas and topped with delicious ingredients and slaws. In our opinion, a well-crafted taco elevates any meal from ordinary to extraordinary

Fortunately, poolside days at Amara Cay pair perfectly with Grilled or Blackened local whitefish topped with chopped iceberg lettuce, pineapple chutney, salsa fresca, queso blanco, and smoked chipotle aioli. Reelburger, our on property restaurant, has gone above and beyond to create a mouth-watering taco, just for you.  Your first bite should be amazing, your second bite incredible. Wash them down with specialty craft cocktails, like Bali Blossom made of Bacardi Superior Rum, Fresh Strawberries, and Basil, Fresh Pressed Lemon Juice, and Organic Agave Nectar, or select from our list of local and international beers. It's a match made in heaven. 


Endless Summer

It’s always summer in the Florida Keys. Save 25% off on your seaside accommodations, and receive a $100 resort credit so you can summer longer.

Book Now



“Love, love, love this place. Everything is pretty, well kept and clean. Palm trees by day & fire pit by night plus all the lawn games, pool, & tiki bar. Do yourself a favor & stay.”
– Christie

“The views are amazing, the pool is tranquil, the beach is spectacular and the rooms are quite nice! Would definitely come back for another stay!”
– Lisa

“Highly recommended this hotel. No need to drive all the way down to Key West. Islamorada has so much to offer. This hotel is a true example of that.”
– Brandon

Experience Our Other Islamorada Resorts

lasiesta logo
pelicancovehotel logo
Postcar Inn Logo