We are excited to be ranked #7 in the 'Top Resorts in the Florida
Keys' list by Condé Nast Traveler Readers’ Choice Awards 2019!

Your Key to a Laid-Back

FLORIDA KEYS EXPERIENCE

Anchored in the laid-back style and carefree atmosphere that makes Islamorada the sport-fishing capital of the world, Amara Cay Resort seamlessly blends recreation with relaxation. Hammocks dot the sandy shoreline, palm trees sway in the breeze, and shimmering oceanfront pools beckon early risers. As the ideal setting to unwind, reconnect, and make lasting memories, it’s no wonder that Amara Cay was voted one of the 'Top Resorts in The Florida Keys' in Condé Nast Traveler Readers’ Choice Awards 2019.

Amara Cay Awards

Selected as one of Jetsetter’s 9 best hotels in the Florida Keys

Where Comfort

MEETS

ELEGANCE

Taking a color cue from our Florida Keys surroundings, our Islamorada guest rooms and suites are beautifully furnished in fresh neutrals with rattan and wood accents, creating an environment that’s both tropical and refined.

VIEW ROOMS

What Sets

US APART

Amenities To write Home about

Amenities To write Home about

Our thoughtfully designed collection of resort amenities and services is what makes us stand out from the rest. From our non-motorized water sports activities to our evening fire pits, there’s always something to do at Amara Cay Resort.

Learn more
food

WHAT'S ON THE MENU AT AMARA CAY

Indulge in made-to-order burgers and other classic American treats at our very own restaurant, ReelBurger, or head to ReelBurger's Tiki Bar for some Keys-inspired cuisine and refreshing island cocktails. We've got something to satisfy any craving.

Learn more
hammock on palm trees

A Laid-Back Island Oasis Awaits

Located in the Florida Keys, halfway between Key West and Miami, Islamorada is known for its crystal clear waters, sandy beaches lined with palm trees, breathtaking orchids and bougainvillea, and one-of-a-kind sunsets.

Learn more

Save With

ISLAMORADA
SPECIALS

Whether you're a Florida resident or valued first-responder, we have an enticing special that is sure to fit your needs. 

VIEW ALL OFFERS

What People

SAY ABOUT US

GREAT EXPERIENCE

We stayed at Amara Cay last week, and it was great. It was clean and the staff was friendly and helpful. The resort had everything we needed, including a shuttle in to town, kayaks, bikes, etc. We had a nice and very relaxing trip. (It helped that the weather was ideal)

SCENIC63700

HIGHLY RECOMMEND!

I can’t fault a single thing with this hotel! As soon as we entered we were checked in by the most helpful and cheerful member of staff! (I wish I’d got his name so I could mention him!) We were upgraded to a suite as we had mentioned we were staying for our anniversary. The room was spacious and well equipped, with a lounge area, kitchen and separate bedroom.

THENINAADVENTURES
Read more reviews
florida green lodging

We Are

HONORED

to be acknowledged by Florida Green Lodging for our commitment to the environment and look forward to keeping Islamorada beautiful for years to come. Amara Cay is dedicated to sustaining the island’s natural bliss and sharing this passion for discovery with our guests and the world.