header image

A Relaxed & Refined Islamorada Resort

Condé Nast Traveler - Readers' Choice Awards 2019

We'reNominated!

Condé Nast Traveler 2019 Readers’ Choice Awards Vote and enter for a chance to win a getaway for two

Vote Now

Your Key to a Laid-Back Florida Keys Experience

Anchored in the laid-back style and carefree atmosphere that makes Islamorada the sport fishing capital of the world, Amara Cay Resort seamlessly blends recreation with relaxation. Hammocks dot the sandy shoreline, palm trees sway in the breeze, and a shimmering oceanfront pools beckons early risers. As the ideal setting to unwind, reconnect, and make lasting memories, it’s no wonder that Amara Cay was selected for Conde Nast Traveler 2017 Readers' Choice Awards as one of the best resorts in the Florida Keys.

Selected as one of jetsetter's 9 best hotels in the florida keys
#9 Best Resort in The Florida Keys

Book Direct Benefits

amara cay homepage intro book direct benefits best rate guarantee

Best Rate Guarantee

  • amara cay king room ocean front

    Where Comfort Meets Elegance

    Taking a color cue from our Florida Keys surroundings, our Islamorada guest rooms and suites are beautifully furnished in fresh neutrals with rattan and wood accents, creating an environment that’s both tropical and refined.

What Sets Us Apart

  • amara cay fire pits and lounge chairs
    1

    Amenities to Write Home About

    Our thoughtfully designed collection of resort amenities and services is what makes us stand out from the rest. From our non-motorized water sports activities to our evening fire pits, there’s always something to do at Amara Cay Resort.

  • amara cay marina and lounge chairs
    2

    A Laid-back Island Oasis

    Located in the Florida Keys, halfway between Key West and Miami, Islamorada is known for its crystal clear waters, sandy beaches lined with palm trees, breathtaking orchids and bougainvillea, and one-of-a-kind sunsets.

  • amara cay burger and onion rings
    3

    What’s on the Menu

    Indulge in made-to-order burgers and more classic American treats at our very own restaurant, Reelburger, or head to Reelburger’s Tiki Bar for some Keys inspired cuisine and refreshing island cocktails.

  • couple on the beach
  • woman window shopping

    Gatherings toRemember

    For anniversaries, wedding receptions, birthdays, and family reunions, Amara Cay Resort offers deliciously catered events for 200 guests.