Food & Drink

Islamorada’s favorite gathering spot for dining indoors and out, Amara Cay Resort’s two restaurants and two bars draw locals and guests for beautifully prepared cuisine that’s anchored in the traditions of Key West. Whether your tastes are simple or sophisticated, trust our culinary team to create a memorable experience in which fresh seafood – the cornerstone of the Islamorada dining – plays a starring role.

Indoors, Oltremare Ristorante infuses traditional Italian cuisine with a tropical twist. Serving breakfast and dinner, this Islamorada newcomer showcases the Keys’ plentiful fresh seafood in modern menus that shine with originality. Breakfast hours are 6:30am - 10:30am, Bar and Lounge are open until 9pm, and Sunday brunch from 11am - 3pm. Reservations are suggested and can be made by calling 305-664-0073. The Oltremare Bar offers an extensive wine list alongside a menu of classic cocktails and signature drinks.


Join us EVERY Sunday for our Sinful Sunday Brunch, featuring delicious plated specialties and our soon to be famous Bloody Mary cart


Every Monday night we're pairing 5 mouthwatering craft martinis with 5 amazing meatball inspired dishes. A match made in heaven! Prices start at $8 per item.


New and unique wines normally sold by the bottle, offered by the glass. Wednesdays, 5:30p - 10p

Sparrows Rum Bar

Open for lunch and dinner daily, Sparrows Rum Bar is a breezy poolside spot for classic American cuisine and tropical cocktails against a backdrop of blue skies and swaying palm trees. Fresh fish tacos, grilled jumbo shrimp and Key lime pie are among the menu highlights. Sparrows serves from 11:30am - 10pm.

One of our favorite pastimes at Amara Cay is to celebrate the sunset and happy hour. We ring the gong every day at 5 pm to signify happy hour and the sun setting with a round of complimentary shots and happy hour specials. Often our team will select one lucky VIP guest to ring the gong to kick off the happy hour for that day.

Lunch Menu Cocktail Menu Wine Menu

Waves Bar

Relax with a drink and appetizer from our poolside bar.